It was Wednesday evening, around 6pm. The traffic was heavy as
always during rush hours. I was coming back home after have run along Charles
River on the Boston side. When I was crossing the bridge that connects Boston
to Cambridge I don’t know why, I started looking to all those people alone
inside their cars, waiting 5 minutes to move just a few meters. Hours and more
hours every day wasted in the crazy traffic. It reminded me a year ago, before
coming to Hult, when I used to spend 40 minutes to drive only 8 kilometers from
home to work and on the way back. I started counting the number of cars with
only one person. Out of 72 cars only 12 had more than one person. I asked
myself, why all those people were not using the T, a bus (mass transportation
options) or even sharing their cars with other people. It would help a lot to
reduce traffic and improve their quality of life.
Someone would argue that is impossible to implement a system that
allows people to share their vehicles with other people, that individuals like
privacy and don’t want to share their sacred time inside their cars with someone
else, that they don’t want to depends on other people schedules to move around
the city, in other words, there will be ten thousand of arguments against the
idea.
Nowadays car-pooling exists as a brave attempt of some to improve
people lives. You can find websites and apps that try to help others to share
their rides. In some cities car-pooling is implemented by the government but using
a fear tactic of punishment (by issuing fines).
What I believe is missing in this whole idea is the use of a
powerful tool to create a real map of possibilities that allows people to share
their cars. This tool is Social Network Analysis. I also believe that in order
to be successful, a study should be made using a small network. We could have
at first a small sample and afterwards expand the results to a large number of
people. It is important not rely on governments since the bureaucracy and
different interests would create barriers against the initiative.
To make things easier I am going to get EF as an example of where
we could start testing the tool to solve the issue. It is a company that cares
about social responsibility and is open to any new idea that helps the
community which is part of the company. The first step would be to collect as many data
as possible. The data would be gender, age, address, friends at work, friends
at “home” (community), time to commute, type of transportation, and distance
from home to work. I think that would be easy to collect these data since we
are talking about only simple information. The HR might have most of them and
if not, it is possible to make a survey with all employees to gather all the
complementary information.
After having all information compiled we advance to the second
step that would be to create the network map. We could use for example UCINET
and NETDRAW as tools to create the map. The third step would be to analyze the
data using network measures. In this case the most important measures are
density and distance of the entire group and degree (number of connections),
betweenness (connector between most important nodes) and closeness (lowest
distance between nodes) of all individuals. What we are looking for here when
analyzing the data is for people that live closer, are related to each other
(as friends) and use car as the way of commuting to work.
Lastly we would have to make the connections available and present
them to all people involved in the organization in order to create awareness of
how these people can start sharing their rides when they come to work and on
the way back.
SNA would be used all the way in this analysis. First in identifying
who are the possible people that can share their cars with other people. Second
in making the connections with these people and showing them all possibilities that
they have when they are looking for someone to commute together. And finally by
integrating possible candidates to an existing network, by using the map
provided during the analysis.
By using SNA, EF in this case, would be able to increase the
number of interactions with its employees outside work (when they are sharing
their rides), reduce its carbon footprint because its employees are going to
use less cars to move around, and help all community by being an example on how
to implement a simple idea that could be expanded to the entire city.
Jose Grecco
Jose Grecco
2 comments:
Nice idea. If you searched a bit, you'd find that SNA is already being used to form carpools, as it combines all the logistical info you need (where you live, who else is en route, what time you need to be at work, etc.) with compatibility issues (what kind of music you like, talker/non-talker, etc.) You put down a number of measures; I would have liked to see more about the rationale for each one. And what about subgroups?
Essentially, you've described a logistics network. What makes SNA'a ability to show the unseen is things like the social connections (e.g. compatibility as above, working on same kind of projects, share interests)that would make the shared commute not only practical but pleasureable and informative.
Thanks for the feedback. I appreciate a lot!!!
Post a Comment